Niti Logic
Niti Logic
Decision Systems, Decoded.
Home Pre-Auths & Appeals Bill Help Resources Book a Session About
Decode My Decision
Token-based platform — single use from $1.99 · Pro packages available
SAMPLE ONLY
Medical Bill Analysis — Tampa General Hospital · Aetna CVS Health · FL
PRISM® ANALYSIS REPORT · BASE VARIANT · SAMPLE OUTPUT · March 2026
SITUATION SUMMARY
⚠ OBSERVATION STATUS ALERT: This patient was classified as outpatient observation — not inpatient — for a 2-night stay. This is the single most impactful variable on this bill. Observation status means all charges bill under outpatient benefits: higher coinsurance, no inpatient deductible protection, and every ancillary service billed separately with separate cost-sharing. The $11,750 patient responsibility is a direct consequence of this classification — and it may be challengeable.
BILL SUMMARY — 2-Night Outpatient Observation · Cardiac Monitoring · Tampa General
Total Billed
$51,840
Contractual Adjustment
$17,200 (Aetna in-network discount)
Aetna Allowed Amount
$34,640
Insurance Paid
$22,890
Patient Responsibility
$11,750 — unverified, see flags below
Admission Classification
Outpatient Observation — NOT Inpatient
Provider
Tampa General Hospital — Academic Medical Center
Insurer
Aetna CVS Health · Employer Fully Insured · FL
Dates of Service
January 15–17, 2026 (2 nights)
ServiceCPTBilledFlag
ED Level 5 Visit — Facility Fee99285$5,840⚠ REVIEW
Observation Room — 48 hours99218/99220$14,200✓ EXPECTED
Continuous Cardiac Telemetry — 48 hours93668$8,600⚠ VERIFY DURATION
Laboratory — Cardiac Panel, BMP, CBC ×380061/85025$4,980✓ EXPECTED
Radiology — Chest X-Ray ×2, ECG ×471046/93000$3,420✓ EXPECTED
IV Medications — Pharmacy (no NDC listed)—$6,200✗ MISSING NDC
Nursing / Observation Care Services99217$4,800âš  REVIEW
Physician Fees (billed separately)—$3,800SEPARATE BILL
TOTAL BILLED$51,840
PRISM identified 5 errors and red flags on this bill. The $11,750 patient responsibility cannot be confirmed as accurate until the Aetna EOB is in hand, admission status is confirmed in writing, and pharmacy charges are itemized with NDC codes. The observation classification alone could account for $4,000–$7,000 in avoidable cost-sharing if a reclassification to inpatient is successful. Financial assistance under IRS 501(r) may further reduce or eliminate the remaining balance.
ERRORS & RED FLAGS IDENTIFIED
Observation Status — 2 Nights of Cardiac Monitoring May Meet Inpatient Criteria Under CMS Two-Midnight Rule
PROBABLE ERROR
This patient was classified as outpatient observation for a 2-night stay involving continuous cardiac monitoring. Under Aetna's employer plan, outpatient benefits apply: outpatient deductible ($2,500–$4,000 typical on employer plans), then 20–40% coinsurance on each ancillary service billed separately. Under inpatient benefits, the deductible is typically lower and all ancillaries are bundled under the admission. The CMS Two-Midnight Rule establishes that patients whose hospital stay is expected to span two midnights generally meet inpatient admission criteria. Continuous cardiac monitoring for a presentation serious enough to require 48 hours of telemetry is a strong candidate for inpatient status. If the treating physician's orders reflect inpatient-level clinical decision-making, a reclassification request is worth pursuing. A successful reclassification could reduce the patient balance by $4,000–$7,000.
CMS Two-Midnight Rule (42 CFR §412.3) — 2-midnight stay generally meets inpatient criteria · Patients have the right to request review of observation status determination
CPT 99285 ED Level 5 Facility Fee ($5,840) — Complexity Documentation Required
PROBABLE
CPT 99285 is the highest-complexity ED E&M code at the facility level. At $5,840, this is Tampa General's facility fee for the ED visit — separate from the attending physician's fee. For Level 5 to be defensible, the medical record must document high medical decision-making complexity per AMA CPT guidelines. Request the ED medical record and confirm the documented complexity level supports the Level 5 designation. If the presenting complaint did not meet high-complexity criteria, a downcode to Level 4 (99284) would reduce this charge by approximately $1,500–$2,000.
AMA CPT guidelines — Level of service must be supported by documented medical decision-making complexity
Cardiac Telemetry ($8,600) — Duration and Continuity Must Be Verified
PROBABLE
$8,600 for 48-hour cardiac telemetry is within range for a major academic medical center — but the single line item does not specify hours monitored or whether monitoring was continuous or intermittent. If monitoring was ordered for 48 hours but discontinued earlier, or if gaps occurred, the billed amount may not reflect actual services rendered. Request nursing notes confirming continuous monitoring for the full 48-hour billed duration. If monitoring was the primary clinical justification for the stay, this also strengthens the Two-Midnight Rule reclassification argument.
Billed services must reflect actual services rendered — duration documentation required for time-based charges
IV Pharmacy Charges ($6,200) — No NDC Codes or Drug Names Listed
POSSIBLE ERROR
$6,200 in pharmacy charges are listed as a single line item with no NDC codes, drug names, dosages, or quantities. This prevents verification of formulary coverage, correct benefit tier application, or duplicate billing across multiple days. This is one of the most common hospital billing gaps — pharmacy charges are frequently where errors hide because patients cannot audit what they cannot see. A fully itemized pharmacy statement with NDC codes is required before this charge can be accepted.
FL Statute §395.301 — hospitals must provide itemized bills upon patient request including drug names and NDC codes for all pharmacy charges
Tampa General Is Nonprofit — IRS 501(r) Financial Assistance May Apply to the Remaining Balance
PROBABLE OPPORTUNITY
Tampa General Hospital operates as a nonprofit academic medical center subject to IRS 501(r) and FL Statute §395.1023. At $11,750, the FAP application is worth pursuing immediately — before making any payment or entering a payment plan. Once payment arrangements are established, FAP eligibility may be affected. Nonprofit hospitals commonly extend assistance to households earning up to 200–400% of the Federal Poverty Level, and may offer sliding-scale reductions at higher income levels. Tampa General's specific thresholds must be obtained directly from Patient Financial Services.
IRS 501(r) — nonprofit hospitals must maintain and apply a Financial Assistance Policy and may not take extraordinary collection action before determining FAP eligibility
RECOMMENDED DOCUMENTATION CHECKLIST
Obtain the Aetna EOB for all January 15–17 claims — Step 1, do not skip
→ "I need the EOB for all claims at Tampa General Hospital for dates of service January 15–17, 2026 — facility fee, observation room, telemetry, labs, radiology, and pharmacy. I also need written confirmation of Tampa General's network status as of January 15, 2026."
REQUIRED
Request written confirmation of observation vs. inpatient classification from Tampa General
→ "I need written confirmation of my admission status for January 15–17, 2026 — specifically whether I was classified as inpatient or outpatient observation, and the date that determination was made and by whom."
REQUIRED
Request fully itemized bill with CPT codes and NDC codes for all pharmacy charges
→ "I am requesting a fully itemized bill listing each charge separately with CPT or revenue code, date of service, quantity, and for all pharmacy charges — drug name, NDC code, dosage, and units administered per day."
REQUIRED
Request Two-Midnight Rule review through Tampa General Patient Advocacy
→ "I am requesting a review of my outpatient observation classification. I was monitored continuously for cardiac symptoms for 2 nights and believe my clinical presentation may meet inpatient criteria under the CMS Two-Midnight Rule. I would like this reviewed by the hospital's utilization review team."
REQUIRED
Apply for Tampa General Financial Assistance before making any payment
→ "I would like to apply for financial assistance under your Financial Assistance Policy. Please send me the application and your income eligibility thresholds." Apply before any payment, payment plan, or collection activity begins.
RECOMMENDED
Check Aetna year-to-date out-of-pocket accumulator
→ Log into aetna.com or call: "What is my year-to-date out-of-pocket accumulator and annual MOOP for 2026? Has the Tampa General claim been applied to my deductible?"
RECOMMENDED
DECISION LOGIC IDENTIFIED
This bill has five identifiable issues. The observation status classification is the highest-impact variable. Under Aetna's employer plan, outpatient observation triggers: ▸ Outpatient deductible (typically $2,500–$4,000 on employer plans) applied first ▸ 20–40% outpatient coinsurance on each ancillary service billed as a separate claim ▸ Pharmacy benefits applied under outpatient drug benefit — potentially higher cost-sharing ▸ No inpatient admission bundling — every service line bills and adjudicates independently If the patient had been classified as inpatient, the cost-sharing would have applied an inpatient deductible (typically lower) with ancillaries bundled under the admission. The $11,750 patient responsibility is a direct product of the observation classification. A Two-Midnight Rule reclassification to inpatient could reduce this balance by $4,000–$7,000 on a typical employer plan. The pharmacy NDC gap and ED Level 5 code are secondary issues — together representing up to $12,040 in charges that cannot be independently verified without the itemized bill.
MISSING INFORMATION OR CRITERIA
▸ Aetna EOB not submitted — Cannot confirm insurance paid $22,890, that the $17,200 contractual adjustment was correctly applied, or that the $11,750 was calculated on the correct benefit tier. The EOB is required before any further action. ▸ Admission status not confirmed in writing — Verbal confirmation from registration is insufficient. Written confirmation from Patient Financial Services identifying inpatient vs. observation classification and the date of that determination is required. ▸ Physician fees not analyzed — The $3,800 physician fee bills separately. Confirm whether the attending, cardiologist, and any consulting physicians were all in-network with Aetna as of January 15, 2026. An out-of-network physician in an in-network facility is a separate issue with No Surprises Act protections. ▸ Prior 2026 out-of-pocket accumulator unknown — If any portion of the annual MOOP has been met from prior 2026 claims, the $11,750 may be partially or fully covered. This must be verified before accepting any balance as final.
MOST LIKELY SUCCESSFUL NEXT STEP
Do not pay this bill. Make two calls before any payment action: Call 1 — Aetna member services. Obtain the EOB and confirm Tampa General's network status. Ask specifically: "Was this claim adjudicated under inpatient or outpatient benefits, and what benefit tier was applied?" Call 2 — Tampa General Patient Financial Services. Request written admission status confirmation and the fully itemized bill with NDC codes. Ask to speak with Patient Advocacy about a Two-Midnight Rule review. The Two-Midnight Rule review and the financial assistance application are your two highest-leverage actions. Pursue both simultaneously — they are independent processes and either one alone could materially reduce the $11,750 balance.
ALTERNATE PATHWAYS
OPTION 1 · Request Inpatient Reclassification Under CMS Two-Midnight Rule
A 2-night cardiac monitoring stay spanning two midnights is a strong candidate for inpatient reclassification. Request the review through Tampa General Patient Advocacy and file a concurrent request with Aetna to review the benefit tier applied. A successful reclassification could reduce the patient balance by $4,000–$7,000 on a typical employer plan. This costs nothing to pursue and is worth doing before making any payment.
OPTION 2 · Apply for Tampa General Financial Assistance (IRS 501(r))
As a nonprofit academic medical center, Tampa General is required under IRS 501(r) and FL Statute §395.1023 to maintain a Financial Assistance Policy. At $11,750, this balance is well within the range where FAP applications are meaningful. Apply immediately — before any payment or payment plan is established. Income-based assistance can reduce the balance to zero for eligible patients.
OPTION 3 · File Formal Written Billing Dispute
Once the EOB and itemized bill are in hand, if errors are confirmed — incorrect benefit tier, unsupported ED Level 5, unverifiable pharmacy charges — file a written billing dispute with Tampa General via certified mail within 30 days. State each disputed charge, cite the supporting evidence, and request a corrected bill within 30 days. Copy Aetna member services.
OPTION 4 · Negotiate Prompt Pay Discount or Payment Plan
If the balance is confirmed after review and financial assistance does not fully apply, ask Tampa General explicitly for a "prompt pay discount" before establishing a payment plan. Lump-sum settlements at 40–60% of the outstanding balance are common practice at nonprofit hospitals for accounts not in collection. Nonprofit hospitals are generally prohibited from charging interest on payment plans for FAP-eligible patients.
ESCALATION GUIDANCE
Level 1 — EOB + Itemized Bill + Two-Midnight Review (now) Obtain both documents and request the reclassification review simultaneously. File written billing dispute if errors are confirmed. Deadline: 30 days from identifying billing errors. Level 2 — Aetna Member Grievance If Aetna applied the wrong benefit tier or failed to correctly apply the contractual adjustment, file a formal member grievance. Aetna is required to respond within specified timeframes under federal and state law. Level 3 — Florida Office of Insurance Regulation Complaint If Tampa General billed beyond the Aetna allowed amount or Aetna failed to correctly adjudicate the claim, file a complaint with the Florida OIR. OIR complaints trigger regulatory review and create a formal record — insurers typically respond more substantively to OIR complaints than to internal grievances alone. Level 4 — IRS 501(r) Complaint If Tampa General failed to screen for FAP eligibility, failed to notify of financial assistance availability, or initiates extraordinary collection action before determining FAP eligibility, file a complaint with the IRS Tax Exempt and Government Entities Division. Nonprofit hospitals risk losing tax-exempt status for 501(r) violations.
NAVIGABILITY OBSERVATION
ACTION CHECKLIST
Do not pay this bill — obtain EOB and itemized bill before any payment action
Call Aetna member services — request EOB for January 15–17, 2026, confirm Tampa General network status, confirm benefit tier applied
Call Tampa General Patient Financial Services — request written admission status confirmation and fully itemized bill with NDC codes
Request Two-Midnight Rule reclassification review through Tampa General Patient Advocacy
Apply for Tampa General Financial Assistance — before any payment or payment plan
Check Aetna year-to-date out-of-pocket accumulator — confirm whether prior 2026 claims have reduced the MOOP
Verify all treating physicians were in-network with Aetna — attending, cardiologist, hospitalist
Map EOB line items against itemized bill — flag any charge where billed amount exceeds Aetna allowed amount
If errors confirmed — file written billing dispute via certified mail within 30 days, copy Aetna
If balance confirmed — ask explicitly for prompt pay discount before establishing a payment plan